The Sunday Salon: Passing the Torch

So I’ve been hanging out with a baby recently; my nephew Xavier. Firstly, it’s kind of soothing to spend out with a content baby. Xa (pronounced “Za”; it’s French) is, obviously, still percolating into a human proper, and it’s fascinating to see him quietly just process the unfamiliar world around him. Soon—all too soon, in fact—Xa will be walking, talking, and, of most interest to me, the only fan and geek in the family, consuming media. As is hosting Trust Me On This, a series of posts where fathers discuss what they want to pass down to their sometimes resistant children, I thought Father’s Day was a perfect opportunity to talk about passing this particular torch.

In the beginning of Ringers, a middling documentary about The Lord of the Rings fandom, the narrator opens by parodying the prologue in Peter Jackson’s The Fellowship of the Ring. When he mentions generational fans, I tear up a little. I know people who were read The Lord of the Rings by their parents or watched Star Trek: The Original Series with them. I have always envied them, because I don’t have anything like that. My parents aren’t fans or fannishly inclined, and my brother is essentially a decade older than I am—even though he did introduce me to The Legend of Zelda (which I believe is part of my bone marrow at this point), we never really bonded over it. It’s nobody’s fault, of course, just circumstance. (I didn’t even know television shows came on weekly until Heroes. Yes, really.) In fact, I think it’s a contributing factor to why I love spending time with fans older than I am; there’s something comforting about the fact that, while my parents were at college, fans were feverishly printing ‘zines and arguing in letter columns. I do try not to talk about this particular aspect of my upbringing, because I think it can come off as whiny, but it’s pertinent here, because I want Xa to have the greatest gift of media consumption: critical thinking.

Henry Jenkins Jr.’s essay “Monsters Next Door” (as collected in Fans, Bloggers, and Gamers), about he and his son’s experience watching Buffy the Vampire Slayer together, opens thusly:

It is assumed that nothing good can come from popular culture, so the advice is always to minimize exposure. But this was very different from the way the media was consumed within my own family. My wife and I were both fans, and we had encouraged our son to play with pop culture; we often had discussions as a family about the media we consumed, and we had through this process taught our son to become a sharp critic of popular culture. (226)

Littlest Jedi

Xa may never be a fan. He might think of The Lord of the Rings as some fantasy novel his aunt read to him when he was little (and made him dress up as her height-accurate Merry to complement a costume; hey, you work with what you have, okay?) and absolutely nothing else. And that is okay. He’s my nephew, I’ll love him no matter what. I don’t want to hand the texts that I love to him in the hopes that he will love them too—although that’s a pretty big part of it—but because I want to teach him how to play with pop culture, just as Jenkins Jr. taught Jenkins the Third. I want to teach him that there is a way to love problematic things that doesn’t start with “I think you’re taking this too seriously”. I want to teach him the power of narrative, balanced with the power of the reader to subvert and correct and riot in the subtext. I want to teach him that consuming media doesn’t mean being passive; in fact, it can mean quite the opposite. Critical thinking, especially with the sheer joy fandom brings to it, is the legacy I want to give him, more than anything else.

This week was my first week at my publishing internship! Slush, slush, slush. I’m really enjoying himself. I went to go see Rock of Ages on Friday, which I mostly liked, and I saw Prometheus on Tuesday, which I wanted to like. I also read Bliss and The Long Earth.

 The Baen Free Library is full of free downloads, including The Shadow of the Lion and On Basilisk Station. Night Shade Books is offering Butcher Bird and Grey as free downloads at the moment. Vertigo Comics is offering free downloads of the first issue of several series, including Fables, The Unwritten, and Y: The Last Man. (And you will go download The Unwritten.) Small Beer Press offers several of their books as free downloads, including Kelly Link’s Magic for Beginners. If I’ve missed your giveaway or freebie, drop me a line!

What stories did your family share with you, if any? Oh, and Happy Father’s Day!

  • Jenkins, Henry. Fans, Bloggers, and Gamers. New York: NYU Press, 2006. Print.

11 thoughts on “The Sunday Salon: Passing the Torch

  1. I feel the same way about generational fan stories. My ex-boyfriend’s parents read The Lord of the Rings to him when he was 6, and I always really wished I could have had an experience like that. Anyway, Xa is lucky to have an aunt like you regardless of whether or not he becomes a fan 🙂

  2. I was fortunate in that my parents, while not really fans, were great consumers of popular culture. They both liked science fiction films and TV shows, so I watched Star Trek with them growing up. My mom collected Edgar Rice Burroughs’ Tarzan books and comics, and I have all of those now. My mom was and is a voracious reader and though we don’t always read the same stuff, she did instill a love of books in me. Every week we talk on the phone about what we’re reading, what books we’re looking forward to and such. So they’ve always supported me in my fannish activities, taking me to SF movies and comic book cons before I could drive.

    A couple of good friends of mine are huge Lord of the Rings fans and they have shared that with their daughter, reading the books to her and taking her to the movies. Her mom also plays Lord of the Rings online with her, which is great. The girl loves Harry Potter and a couple of years ago they gave her a birthday party where they had done up their house as Hogwarts and she and all her friend came as characters from the book. Since I’m the biggest guy they know they got me to show up dressed as Hagrid and deliver a slightly dented cake. I Banged on the door and everything. Anyone need a slightly used pink umbrella?

  3. For the most part, my parents weren’t and still aren’t really into fandom or popular media. My dad loved Star Trek, and subsequently introduced me and my sister to it, but he could never understand why or how the two of us got so into it. (The same went for Adventures in Odyssey, a kid’s radio show that I just loved and wrote fanfiction and had lots of great discussions with other fans on a message board that was centered around the show.) Star Trek, Star Wars (the Original Trilogy) and AIO were the only two items of popular media that I was allowed to consume, anyway. They eventually let me read and watch LOTR, and again got very befuddled with how much I loved it and discussed it. Any other fandoms I got into I discovered on my own (Harry Potter, Babylon 5, Marvel and DC, Doctor Who).

    I’m glad that my parents offered my sister, brother and I some opportunities to watch and read popular media and hence, get into fandoms, although I do wish they would understand certain aspects of our passions, instead of insisting that we’re wasting our time and none of these things will help us get through college or get a job. I’m really looking forward to the next generation of our family, though. Any future parents in my family are all deeply entrenched in fannish activities, so it’ll be fun to see how it all works out. And I can’t wait to see your Eowyn and Merry cosplay idea come to fruition!

  4. You will be a rock star of an aunt. An huge thanks for turning me onto Social Justice League. I just spent nearly 30 minutes perusing through their backlog and am bookmarking it for further exploration.

  5. My parents are not fans of anything. They did have a used bookstore and did give me a love of reading, but they have never been fans of anything. In fact, my mother was a bit scared when I started reading fantasy (all she knew about fantasy, was those role players who had killed someone…!). I do hope to pass some fandom on to my girls – in fact, I’m going to steal this idea and write a blog post about which things I would like to pass on to them, if that’s okay?

Your Thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s