Review: Out of the Silent Planet

Out of the Silent Planet by C. S. Lewis

After Narnia Week, I was getting curious about Lewis’ novels for adults. While I’ve had Till We Have Faces on my reading list for a while, I’ve had The Space Trilogy recommended to me—specifically, Perelandra, the sequel that deals with a planet in the throes of its own creation myth. But y’all know how I am about series; I have to start at the beginning. (I am getting better about this, however, but when it comes to old-school speculative fiction, I have to.) So Out of the Silent Planet passed into my hands as required reading. Which it pretty much stayed.

Out of the Silent Planet opens with Dr. Elwin Ransom, the eminent philologist, being abducted by an old schoolfellow and his partner in crime. When Ransom wakes up on a spaceship, his entire worldview changes. Weston and Devine, his captors, bring Ransom to the planet of Malacandra to hand over to the mysterious sorns, but the fearful Ransom flees and falls in with the hross, whose language he learns. The more Ransom learns about the planet, the more he comes to love it—but the villainous Weston and Devine are still on the loose, and Ransom is soon summoned to the mysterious Oyarsa…

When I write up the blurbs for books I’m reviewing, I do my best to try and make the plot sound punchy. That above summary cuts pretty far into the novel, because not a lot happens. To be fair, this is because Out of the Silent Planet is a novella at best—at 158 pages, the covers of the 1996 hardcover edition I’d rented from the library weighed more than the actual text. But it’s also because not much really happens in the book. It ends with a postscript from Lewis, talking about his own correspondence with Ransom (presented as a pseudonym for an actual Oxford don, which is quickly dropped in Perelandra), and an excerpt from a letter of Ransom’s, where he talks about how his visit with the hross is, to him, the entire pinnacle of his visit to Malacandra, and how sad he is that Lewis couldn’t just dedicate the novel to it. But, in a way, he does. Lewis is so enamored with the world he created that a lot of time is spent on Ransom’s delight in discovering a new culture, and the actual narrative isn’t focused on too much.

In fact… well, let me back up. I was lucky enough to have a chance to attend a short workshop with Benjamin Percy when he was here for the Agnes Scott Writer’s Festival. His workshop focused on the structure of a story and the tension between the emotional arc and the narrative arc of a story. I’ve been finding this very useful; in fact, I might write up a Sunday Salon post on the subject, because it’s been helping me sort out my eternal pet peeve, the concept of “literary fiction”. (One of my professors, God bless her, expresses nothing but serene confusion when the phrase floats into her line of sight.) While Out of the Silent Planet is light on the narrative arc (man is kidnapped to planet, man comes to love planet…), it’s also light on the emotional arc. It’s something I noticed in The Chronicles of Narnia; the internal turmoil the kids should be feeling over becoming children again and discovering the Narnia they loved is dead and gone is completely glossed over. I was really hoping that was a function of the audience he was writing for—Out of the Silent Planet was published before The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe. To be fair, he does; Ransom’s experience of space as a sea of light instead of the usual cold dark of deep space is spiritually buoyant.

But for the most part, it’s a philosophical exercise in an alien culture instead of a story. (To be fair, I confused this with Perelandra in the beginning, but I think the comment still stands.) There’s some business with a corrupted angel having some control over Earth, but it’s hardly presented as urgent. Malacandra, which Lewis details exhaustively, boasts three sapient species, and their interaction with one another and with Ransom lead to thoughtful commentary. Hyoi, the hross Ransom becomes especial friends with, talks about how death gives life meeting; Ransom ponders the demonic and angelic aspects of the hross; and one alien tells Ransom that humans are so corrupted because they have no other species to compare world views. Given the Lewis I know from The Chronicles of Narnia and The Magician’s Book, that last one was particularly affecting.

But I still don’t know if I can push through the general disappointment to Perelandra.

Bottom line: Out of the Silent Planet is more of a philosophical exercise in an alien culture than a story, with little focus on Ransom’s emotional life and less on the overarching narrative. Not awful, but certainly not very engaging.

I rented this book from the public library.

11 thoughts on “Review: Out of the Silent Planet

  1. A very interesting review, although I believe you may have accidentally overused “to be fair” in your assessment. I haven’t read this one – what is the quality of the prose? Is it well-written?

  2. Out of the Silent Planet is by far the weakest in the trilogy. I know just what you mean about the emotional distance. Perelandra has a much stronger narrative arc and improves on the emotional arc too. And That Hideous Strength is better still. although it has its own special oddities. It’s … unsettling. It took me a couple of readings to decide that I mostly liked it.

    But Till We Have Faces is by far the best of Lewis’s fiction. Better on every level.

  3. I can understand your disappointment, though I tend to lap up philosophical exercises of alien cultures even if “not a lot happens,” as long as that exercise interests me sufficiently. I don’t really think that the emotional/narrative arc is necessarily essential for a good book, either, nor do I think drama is inherently necessary, but I do recognize that it’s seen as highly desirable. One of my favourite novels is Olaf Stapledon’s “Star Maker,” and it doesn’t even really have characters at all: it reads more like a documentary than anything else.

    • Interesting! Stories, for me, require characters to care about, because I think characters ought to be the movers and shakers of their worlds and thus the creators of their own stories. Thanks for offering a different perspective!

      • I see why you don’t find Lewis very enjoyable with this approach. I believe everythink he wrote is a kind of philosophical excercise even Till We Have Faces. And I think you need to be a fan of Christian belief to really enjoy Out of the Silent Planet. I do 🙂

  4. I agree with Ajalon. As a Christian I found the whole concept absolutely FASCINATING that God has created more than one populated planet and has revealed Himself to all of them. The business with the fallen angel and earth is clearly Satan and the fall of man. Lewis was indicating that because of our evil behavior we are silent; we no longer communicate with the thriving life of the universe or with God. I actually read this alongside 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea and found that to be a great pairing. Also, Ransom changes greatly. He is a very dynamic character in my opinion and Lewis changes him just as he desires the reader to be changed. Also as a language major in college I found all of the anthropology and language highlights to be interesting as well. Also, I had gotten the idea in my head that Oyarsa was really Jesus or someone like him and so ate up the book in probably 2 days trying to get to the part where they met.

  5. Pingback: Retrospective: Out of the Silent Planet | Sentient Faith

  6. Painfully drab of mind! That’s my opinion of the review not the book. I absolutely love the cosmic trilogy it’s incredibly gripping, beautifully and intelligently written. If you like the chronicles of Narnia you will also love this. Also calling all Tolkien fans you will love this too.
    I would use the word “Cosmic” as the perfect description as well as the context. If this trilogy doesn’t blow your mind then it’s safe to assume your soul is dried up and you might aswell just watch reality TV and listen to rap.

Your Thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s