The Literary Horizon: Belinda, An Old-Fashioned Girl

Despite all the problems I have with the term “classics”, I am fond of the books that often fall under that tyrannical label. There’s (usually) a reason they’ve persisted in popular culture for so long, and they’re often a window into a time period and a style of writing that we just don’t have anymore. Also, they’re usually free eBooks, which is also an enormous consideration.

Belinda by Maria Edgesworth

The lively comedy of this novel in which a young woman comes of age amid the distractions and temptations of London high society belies the challenges it poses to the conventions of courtship, the dependence of women, and the limitations of domesticity. Contending with the perils and the varied cast of characters of the marriage market, Belinda strides resolutely toward independence. Admired by her contemporary, Jane Austen, and later by Thackeray and Turgenev, Edgeworth tackles issues of gender and race in a manner at once comic and thought-provoking. The 1802 text used in this edition also confronts the difficult and fascinating issues of racism and mixed marriage, which Edgeworth toned down in later editions.

via Amazon

…well, I’ve read all of Austen, so this is really just a logical choice, isn’t it?

Eva at A Striped Armchair absolutely loved it, which is probably what motivated me to put it on my list in the first place. Katherine at A Girl Walks Into a Bookstore also enjoyed it.

Belinda was published in 1801.

An Old-Fashioned Girl by Louisa May Alcott

Alcott, beloved author of Little Women and other magnificent children’s classics, brings to life the tale of Polly Milton, a young girl who leaves her simple country life to stay at the home of her wealthy city cousins. But can plain Polly enjoy sophisticated city life without changing? This unforgettable story about being true to yourself continues to inspire.

You might question my pairing of this title with Belinda, but the very thought of comparing and contrasting Alcott with a writer often compared to Austen just makes me giggle. (And now I’m imagining Elizabeth cutting Jo down to size, never mind the fact they would have lived at different ends of a century.) In any case, someone on LiveJournal mentioned that they loved this more than Little Women, so I decided to give it a shot.

Jenny at Shelf Love really enjoys this book, especially in its second half, where everything picks up. But Nicole at Linus’s Blanket, although she usually loves Alcott, found it frustratingly preachy and treacly.

An Old-Fashioned Girl was published in 1869.

7 thoughts on “The Literary Horizon: Belinda, An Old-Fashioned Girl

  1. both of these books sound really good–and I like that they are free too. Sometimes I think the classics are refreshing. It’s nice to turn back the clock to simpler times and less fantastical plots.

    • They are refreshing, but I can’t say I agree about them being simpler and less fantastical—some of the scheming and plotting in classics, such as The Count of Monte Cristo, would put the most florid of modern writers to shame.

  2. An Old-Fashioned Girl is a smidge preachy, but not particularly preachier than Alcott’s other books. A little bit of preachiness goes with the territory. It’s still an excellent book! Not my favorite but I love it a lot.

  3. Yay for Belinda! 😀 Although, I didn’t know beforehand that Maria Edgeworth was compared to Jane Austen, so I hope that doesn’t skew your expectations. lol

    I haven’t read that Alcott, but I enjoyed last year Eight Cousins despite the preachiness. 😉 I must say, I think LM Montgomery lives up to my adult reading self far more than LM Alcott!

Your Thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s