Booking Through Thursday: Not in Theaters

And–the reverse of last week’s question. Name one book that you hope never, ever, ever gets made into a movie (no matter how good that movie might be).

Any novel that’s very internal ought to be shied away from—any examples of books I hope will never be made into a movie have, unfortunately, already been filmed; Atonement, The Lovely Bones, Jane Eyre (that review’s going up tomorrow), just to name a few. Film is a visual medium, which makes it extremely difficult to get the internal narratives across clearly.

8 thoughts on “Booking Through Thursday: Not in Theaters

  1. I read The Lovely Bones but passed on the movie; didn’t need to see certain parts of the book on screen. I’m looking forward to your thoughts on Jane Eyre too. I wanted to see it because I loved the book so much but haven’t yet.

  2. I read Atonement a few years before the film came out. I really thought the book was unfilmable but the movie surprised me. There’s no way it could capture all the internal aspects of the book, true, but I thought it was an excellent adaptation nonetheless and I own it.

  3. I like this question but have totally blanked on any books I would never want to see made into a movie. I just feel like most books could turn into awesome movies (or, well, I am really envisioning most of them as BBC miniseries) if the right people were managing them.

  4. I actually really liked what Joe Wright did with ‘Atonement’ (though perhaps would have felt differently if I’d read the book first).

    I have to say that I hope they never make a film of any book I loved as a child, because it could never capture what I imagined – so, almost anything by Arthur Ransome, anything by Diana Wynne Jones (though I didn’t mind ‘Howl’s Moving Castle’), The Dark is Rising books (one of which has already, apparently, been murdered by Hollywood), and so on…

Your Thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s