Review: A Clash of Kings

A Clash of Kings by George R. R. Martin

It feels a little odd, I have to be honest, to be getting into Martin this late in the game—while I’m getting excited for the HBO adaptation and forcing myself to space out the books, I’ve encountered people who, quite rationally, want to wait until the entire series is finished (or in a position to be finished) and other people who are quite openly hostile about it, such as a gentleman I encountered in a book store who warned me off the books. (I ignored him.) However, I also think I came in at just the right time—I’ve a sneaking suspicion that A Dance with Dragons, the fifth book in the series, will be released as a tie-in with the show. (Supporting my theory is Martin claiming he can see the light at the end of the tunnel in this podcast last month. But I’d take that well-salted.) But however it works out, I’m glad I’ve gotten into this series. Spoilers for A Game of Thrones abound, so beware!

A Clash of Kings picks up where A Game of Thrones left off; after the death of King Robert Baratheon and the execution of Eddard Stark, a civil war (later known as The War of the Five Kings) breaks out in Westeros. While Robert’s heir, the thirteen year old Joffrey, sits on the Iron Throne of Westeros, Robb Stark, Eddard’s eldest son, has become the King in the North, while Robert’s brothers, Stannis and Renly, struggle to gain their brother’s throne from a child who is not his royal issue. Across the sea, Daenaerys Targaryen, the last heir of the house Robert Baratheon took the throne from, continues to gather her forces to retake Westeros, aided—and hindered—by her newly hatched dragons. And in the north, on the Wall that defends Westeros’ northern border, the men of the Night’s Watch continue to contend with dark forces and the wild people of the North, without help from a shattered kingdom more concerned with their own struggles.

I’m very impressed by Martin’s use of scope in the novel on two levels. First, there’s simply the sheer amount of people and stories he’s dealing with, although they can be easily herded into three main storylines; as in the acknowledgements for A Game of the Thrones, Martin offers up a smug remark that he’s thoroughly earned—as he says, the devil is in the details. But there’s also the way he plays with scope, zooming in and out at will, showing us this civil war from the perspective of people in all stations of life and in geographic perspective; Daenaerys, living across the sea, learns of Robert’s death halfway through A Clash of Kings, living among vibrant and diverse cultures on an entirely different continent. It shows you just how petty war can be, especially when we’re dealing with Joffrey, a brutally sadistic and gorgeous (the two main traits of House Lannister, of which he is doubly) teenage boy playing at king. There’s a spectacular moment where Joffrey, being the bloodthirsty sadist he is, gets carried away sentencing someone to death—and cuts himself on the Iron Throne, which is infamously composed of half-melted weapons. This is war, in all its horror, violence, and, yes, occasional glory, as Tyrion Lannister, the dwarf known as the Imp, finally experiences battle fever. It’s quite an accomplishment.

Another accomplishment on Martin’s part is rendering every character as utterly human. I found myself growing fond of Stannis Baratheon, the late Robert’s older brother, a stern and stoic man who adheres to a high moral code. While I do admit I have to flip to the House listings in the back to get my bearings, every viewpoint character and most other characters are distinctive, well-written, and complex. Martin particularly succeeds in writing Sansa and Arya Stark, Eddard’s young daughters. I don’t think I’ve ever read a book by a male author that deals with a girl’s menarche, but he does it quite well for Sansa, who realizes that, now that she can bear children, she’s in even more danger from Joffrey, to whom she’s betrothed. I think I’m pulling out Sansa and Arya because they represent the ends of a spectrum; Sansa’s innocence, optimism, and belief in the good of people is slowly being destroyed, while Arya turns brutally practical and bitterly rejecting the gods in the face of all the awful things that happen to her. There’s plenty more where that came from—Theon Greyjoy, a seafarer who seeks to take the Starks’ Winterfell, Ser Davos Seaworth, a smuggler turned knight for Stannis Baratheon, and Catelyn Stark, who is still reeling from the death of her husband.

I do have to say that A Clash of Kings—indeed, any doorstopper fantasy series—can be fatiguing. It’s a well-built story—an assault on the capital forms the solid climax—but it’s so complex (although never too complex) and there’s so much of it that I’d advise readers to pace yourself. (Mostly because I didn’t, spending all day New Year’s Eve with it.) While I’m looking forward to picking up A Storm of Swords, I’m also very happy to pace myself. Perhaps after the show’s first season…

Bottom line: Martin does it again; a thrillingly dark and complex world populating by equally dark and complex characters from all walks of life, organically struggling for power—a struggle that, in the context of the supernatural forces beyond the Wall and the rising threat of Daenaerys Targaryen, is revealed for the petty struggle it is. But remember to pace yourself; it’s complex and there’s a lot of it. (And a lot more where it came from…)

I bought this book from a thrift store.

16 thoughts on “Review: A Clash of Kings

  1. releasing Dance as an HBO series tie in? if true, whatever PR person came up with that, I want to hug them (yay! I’ll finally be able to read dance!) and smack them for a cheesy marking ploy.

    Don’t worry about feeling like you’re late to the game, it just means you’ll have to wait a shorter time to read the 5th book!

    Clash might be my favorite book so far in the series, as since we already know all the characters and places, we can get into the nitty gritty of what’s going on, and get that plot and various wars moving forward, and fast.

    It’s funny, all the characters who were were told to love in book one, your feelings start to change about them in book 2. and the opposite for the characters we were told to hate. . . maybe they’re not such horrible people after all. Or well, in some cases (Joffrey, I’m looking at you!), they are.

    I love Martin’s writing style for the same reasons you do – there is so much going on, so many characters, but it never feels overwhelming or over complex. I think I have major character ADHD, as I often have problems keeping track of everyone in these sprawling ensemble novels with multiple POVs. But I’ve never had a problem keeping track with Martin. The family listings in the back are a HUGE help.

  2. I agree. There’s so much going on but it never feels overwhelming. Each character feels complete and complex without causing too much confusion over who is who.

    I’m glad to know the series is holding up. I wanted to jump right into this one after finishing A Game of Thrones but made myself wait. For doorstopper fantasy books, I need to pace or I get sick of it all too fast.

  3. I waited over a year before reading A Clash Of Kings and I think I’ll wait at least that long before reading A Storm Of Swords. I’m doing that partially because pacing is so important with these books. There is a loose theme through both, even though the story is clearly open for more events to happen.

    I’m looking forward to the HBO series because the casting for it is phenomenal.

    I just want Martin to finish writing the series instead of editing anthology books or writing episodes of TV shows.

  4. This is another series my husband really likes. He was wary of getting into it, since Martin has that reputation for never, ever finishing the next book, but he finally caved and devoured the whole series quickly. It’s another of those fantasy series I think I might end up enjoying, so I didn’t read your whole post, just in case I do pick it up at some point.

  5. Very good review. I am one of those with mixed feelings about the series. In part I am in awe of his ability to draw characters and situations that are so human and real. In part I am furious that he has let his story get so far out of control. Over half of A Feast For Crows, for example, could have been cut out. And six years between books? Really? With no “previously on…” summaries? REALLY?

    Still, as you note, he makes you sympathize with even the most abhorrent characters (Jamie Lannister? How does he make me care about Jamie Lannister? Masterful).

    • “Previously on…” just makes me think of Heroes, to be totally honest—not appropriate for books. I did feel here that Martin got you adjusted to the situation well enough (which is all I ask; obviously, you want to start a series at the beginning, but an installment ought to at least function as a novel unto itself).

  6. Spacing these books out is a very, very good idea. I read the first three in a rush, one right after the other, and by the end I was feeling not only fatigued, but also caught by some annoyances (Martin’s subtle but definite misogyny, for one) that wouldn’t have been nearly so bad if I’d encountered it a little at a time.

    I do love this series, though, and am torn between my desire to re-read it before the show starts (I know there are entire plotlines I’ve forgotten in the 5 years since I’ve read it, not to mention the details) and my utter frustration with the publishing schedule.

  7. I need to get back to this one. I came to this series late in the game myself, having FINALLY picked up the first book because my guilt was becoming overwhelming. I have a dear friend who LOVES this series and he had been patiently waiting for years for me to read it. I tore through A Game of Thrones as if it was only a few hundred pages long and dove right into Clash, but then got distracted by other things.

    I’ve been impressed with what Martin has done. I admit I was loathe to start because of the fact that he hasn’t finished with these. But then I saw him at a live reading this past summer and he so intrigued me that I decided I wouldn’t (hopefully) be getting into a Jordanesque epic that would never end.

    Looking forward to the HBO series.

  8. Pingback: Review Revisited: George R. R. Martin – A Clash of Kings « Fyrefly's Book Blog

  9. Pingback: Book Review: #42 – A Clash of Kings by George RR Martin (audio) | Let's eat Grandpa!

  10. Pingback: The Sunday Salon: Bookish Questions « The Literary Omnivore

  11. Pingback: Book Review: A Clash of Kings by George R.R. Martian (3/5) | Taking on a World of Words

Your Thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s