Review: Persuasion

Persuasion by Jane Austen

I’m really going to miss my Jane Austen class, I’ve got to say–although I’m certainly looking forward to my young adult and children’s literature class next semester. (Why yes, my school is awesome.) While even I, chin deep in mass paperback fantasy, had heard of Mansfield Park, I had never heard of Persuasion. My only acquaintance with it was encountering the DVD of the film adaptation while poking through my local Blockbuster, trying to find a copy of Star Wars Lucas hasn’t messed with. (A Herculean task, I assure you–ancient VHS tapes are my only recourse, but I digress.) Still, it was a calming 250 pages compared to Emma, and I picked it up with relief.

Persuasion follows Anne Elliot, the daughter of a very self-absorbed, classist, and recently impoverished baronet. In order to make up the lost money, Sir Walter Elliot reluctantly rents out Kellynch Hall to Admiral and Mrs. Croft and replaces to Bath with Anne’s eldest sister, Elizabeth. Anne remains behind with her youngest sister, now a Mrs. Musgrove, and discovers that Mrs. Croft’s brother is Captain Frederick Wentworth–a man she once was engaged to, when his fortunes were yet to be made, and which engagement she broke off at the suggestion of her friend and mentor, Lady Russell. Now twenty-seven and still unmarried, Anne is unsure how to deal with the reappearance of a man she still might love.

After getting through Mansfield Park and Emma, Persuasion felt a bit… spare. It’s a very simple and straightforward story; Anne deals with the downturn in family fortunes and deals with the reappearance of Captain Wentworth. The focus is on the Elliot family, albeit spread out into the Musgroves, whom Anne’s younger sister, Mary, married into. It’s very clean and enjoyable, but it still feels a bit skeletal– perhaps I feel this way because I’m reading these in the order Austen wrote them, and it’s hard to see her backtrack, in a sense, to the cleaner plots of Pride and Prejudice and Northanger Abbey. I did like that Persuasion focused on Anne, a quiet but bright “older woman” (by Regency standards, naturally) who is moderate in her spending but unfortunately ignored by her family. In this class, we were asked to write some thoughts down that could, hopefully, turn into a paper; I wrote about Anne’s fascination with the Navy, which neatly mirrors the involvement of the Navy in Austen’s own life–two of her brothers were in it. Even as Anne remains unsure of Wentworth’s intentions, she finds nautical people who like and appreciate her–Captain Benwick, whom she recommends some hearty prose to lift him out of his poetic doldrums, and especially both of the Crofts. While I was very pleased that Lady Russell was never vilified (in fact, Anne boldly defends her earlier decision to Wentworth), I was also pleased that Sophia was presented as the sort of woman Anne wanted to be.

In fact, the lack of vilification of Lady Russell can perhaps explain the slow, sauntering pace of Persuasion; there’s no antagonist to provide the stakes that Anne, as a baronet’s daughter with, if not wealth, security, lacks. While Austen’s books are hardly page turners, they’re still quite engaging because there are stakes involved for these young women, even Emma, who, instead of securing herself a place in the world, needs to secure her head out of the romantic clouds. Anne doesn’t particularly grow over the novel; she’s always made her wants and desires clear, it’s just that her father and sister completely ignore her. (In one of the meanest scenes, Elizabeth confides to a Mrs. Clay, a woman clearly angling for Sir Walter’s hand in marriage, that she values her more than her own sister–which, of course, Anne overhears with perfect clarity.) She simply finally gets her chance to shine, by marrying Wentworth (like that was ever in question!) and becoming a sailor’s wife. She’s constantly useful and rational throughout the novel; a lovely character and ideal woman, but not the most engaging of Austen’s heroines. (Perhaps that’s why you rarely hear of Anne Elliot in popular culture, as opposed to sarcastic Elizabeth or controlling Emma.)

But unlike Austen’s other novels, which usually reaffirm a fairly conservative view of class (especially in Persuasion’s sister books, Mansfield Park and Emma), Austen takes some swipes at the old money families she’s been idolizing. Sir Walter and Margaret are arrogant, if elegant, snobs, who trip over their own feet trying to please the exceedingly dull Lady Dalrymple and are confused when Anne won’t break off a date with an impoverished and very ill schoolfriend to have dinner with them; even William Elliot, a cousin proposed as a romantic match for Anne (and thankfully turned down, as he turns out to be quite the rogue), teasingly reminds Anne of the difference between the good company (the Dalrymples) and the best company (lively, modest banter). I did quite enjoy the emphasis on the Navy and the self-made man in Persuasion, but between the low stakes and the fairly static Anne, it doesn’t stand up to the rest of Austen’s canon–which is quite a shame, as Austen died a year after completing this.

Bottom line: Austen’s last novel makes romantic confusion stand in for conflict for Anne Elliot, the baronet’s daughter who identifies much more with sailors and their wives. Anne, as the oldest Austen heroine, is nicely bright and quiet (although she does stand up for herself), but her character remains mostly static through the novel, and there’s no particular need for her to get married to secure herself in society, which makes for a slow story. Austen’s last was not her best, although it’s still worth a read.

I bought this book from Barnes & Noble.

13 thoughts on “Review: Persuasion

  1. I’ve heard a lot of people say they like Persuasion the best of all Austen’s books. It’s been way too long since I read it for me to be able to make a sensible statement either way, but I feel like I really loved it last time through. Maybe…

  2. I liked this book a lot – more than Emma, at any rate – and I think it’s entirely down to how well I related to the protagonists. I found Emma to be a little bit obnoxious, whereas I read Persuasion when I was eight-and-twenty myself, so I found Anne to be thoroughly relatable and sympathetic.

    Also, the DVD adaptations are really good – I like Anne better in the 1995 version, but Wentworth in the 2007 version is dreeeeeeamy. 🙂

  3. I quite liked this book, more than I was expecting. It might be one of my favorites; I like it’s elegant simplicity. Some theorize that Austen finished this rather hastily, as she was ill when she writing this, and that’s partially why it’s so slender.

  4. ‘Persuasion’ is actually my favourite of Austen’s novels. I love Anne and her quiet struggles – there’s actually quite a lot of emotion in her, even if she seldom expresses it – and all the characters are well drawn.

    One minor point, Anne’s elder sister is called Elizabeth, not Margaret. Or is in my copy of the book, anyway!

    I haven’t seen the 2007 adaptation Fyrefly mentions, but I loved Amanda Root and Ciaran Hinds in the 1995 BBC version.

  5. I’m with Ela, this is actually my favorite of all of Austen’s books. I love that Anne and Wentworth’s love survives their 7 years apart. Some of Austen’s other books, like P&P (thoughI love it too), base their love on a few short interactions. I know that’s how it was back then, but there’s something beautiful about having all that time apart and knowing that you’re still in love with that person. Great review!

  6. Your school IS awesome! I wish I could take a class on YA lit. (Though I will be writing an essay on YA for one of my classes, which I guess is second best :P).

    I have long ago decided this was going to be my next Austen. Now I just need to actually pick it up.

  7. You have a Jane Austen class? I’m so jealous. 😛 Anyway, great review. When it comes to Austen books, Pride and Prejudice and Sense and Sensibility top my list, but Persuasion comes in a close third. Emma was a little too much for me.

  8. I remember being a little underwhelmed by Persuasion, but I also remember someone telling me that it grows on you upon re-reading. Emma and Pride & Prejudice are my favorites – at the moment.

  9. Pingback: Advent with Austen: Persuasion by Jane Austen « The Sleepless Reader

Your Thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s