Review: A Game of Thrones

A Game of Thrones by George R. R. Martin

George R. R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire is one of the biggest series in modern fantasy. It’s an epic series of seven planned novels with only four currently published, complete with a fandom so ravenous Neil Gaiman has had to remind them that “George R. R. Martin is not your bitch”. Each book is, of course, thoroughly massive; even in paperback, A Game of Thrones runs over 800 pages, and the novels are regularly split into two books overseas.

In short, A Song of Ice and Fire can be pretty intimidating.

But the HBO adaptation of A Game of Thrones is due out next year, and it’s filled to the brim with good actors that I like, including Lena Headey and Nikolaj Coster-Waldau. Because I know I’m going to watch it, I decided to finally suck it up and dig in.

A Game of Thrones is set in Westeros, also known as the Seven Kingdoms, a land where summers last years and winters lifetimes. After the throne was taken in a bloody civil war by his friend Robert Baratheon, Eddard “Ned” Stark, Lord of Winterfell, has tended to the North and his family with nary a thought of court. When King Robert comes calling with the news that the King’s Hand, Jon Arryn, has died and offers Ned the position, Ned reluctantly takes it in order to discover the truth of Arryn’s death. Meanwhile, across the sea, the last daughter of the royal house Robert wrested control from has married a great warlord in an attempt to gather forces to retake Westeros. But all these mortal concerns pale in the face of the strange and supernatural stirrings beyond the Wall in the North, to the horror of the ever-vigilant Night’s Watch, a brotherhood sworn to protecting the Kingdoms from what lies beyond. Summer is fading; winter is coming.

A Game of Thrones is epic in scope, which means lots and lots of characters. Martin helpfully provides a few pages on the major houses in Westeros that covers nearly all of the main characters, although it would have been much appreciated at the beginning of the book. (I was occasionally scared that they were in the back because they had spoilers. They do not, so feel free to check.) There’s also the ever helpful fantasy map at the beginning of Westeros, although we’re left to our own devices when we visit Daenerys, the last daughter of the House Targaryen, across the sea. Martin’s worldbuilding is pretty much flawless. I was a bit concerned with the supposed “barbarians” Daenerys lives among, but we’re quickly shown that’s the attitude of her racist brother, not her. There’s a real depth and detail to everything, and only once is he tempted to crowbar a little exposition in concerning the supposedly mythical Children of the Forest, which I could forgive, as it adds a colonial narrative to Westeros. Martin does his best to make this fantasy world as real as our world is, and he wildly succeeds–especially in action and battle scenes that drive home the cost of war.

It’s also amazing how he manages to make a book that’s 700 pages long in hardback and 800 in paperback so readable and enthralling. I will readily admit I got a little fatigued towards the end–the last doorstopper fantasy series I read was Harry Potter, and it’s been a while for me. It’s no fault of Martin’s. I think this readability can be chalked up to the almost thriller-like structure of the book. We alternate between characters every chapter, and each chapter is short and usually ends on a great hook. Each chapter reflects its third-person narrator–for instance, Sansa, Ned’s daughter, is prim, proper, and romantic, while her sister, Arya, is a stubborn little tomboy. While there’s plenty of characters who are young, the narration manages to reflect their youth without dumbing them down. It’s ridiculously well done.

All of this, on its own, would be superb fantasy. What makes A Game of Thrones truly great is how human each and every character is. There is no such thing as purely good or purely evil. Even Ned Stark, who is a beacon of goodness in these dark times, has his faults–Jon Snow, his bastard son, thinks of him as almost perfect, but always remembers he cheated on his wife. Some of the more flamboyant “bad guys”–Queen Cersei, Prince Joffrey, and Viserys–don’t have as much depth as the rest of the cast, but it’s still there, and I have every confidence that Martin expands on them in later books in the series. My favorite characters ended up being Arya, the aforementioned tomboy (of course, right?), and Tyrion Lannister, the dwarf son of the politically powerful and physically gorgeous Lannister family, whose sarcasm, wry sense of humor, and motivation were marvelous. (I sensed, for some reason, a touch of Truman Capote in him, which I thoroughly enjoyed.) But that’s just the tip of the iceberg; each character is fully realized and almost heartbreakingly human–honorable and stubborn Ned, Daenerys coming into her own in a strange land, and, almost worst of all, Sansa’s realization that the world is not as the songs and fairy tales have rendered it. It’s truly a marvelous feat.

I look very much forward to the next one, although I may wait until next year to space them out.

Bottom line: A Game of Thrones boasts an absolutely solid and realistic fantasy world, as well as a thriller-like structure that makes the 800 pages fly by–but what truly makes it great are how human each character is, never wholly good or wholly evil. If you like fantasy, or even just political intrigue, this is a must read.

I bought this book from a local thrift store.

19 thoughts on “Review: A Game of Thrones

  1. Hmmm…my current fantasy to read list is long but I think I need to add this one. It’s sounds like my kind of fantasy. And, I like doorstopper books. 🙂

  2. LOL at Gaiman’s post. 🙂 Chris recommend this to me, and I really want to give it a go, but I’m wary since the series is only halfway done. *ponders*

  3. It’s fantastic — I’m only on book three, though, and I’m so exhausted by the length of the previous two that I’m taking a break.

    Don’t worry — everyone gets intriguing development. Like you know how Sansa and Arya could have become stereotypical “boring sister” and “spunky likable sister?” Nope. . .there will be development! And of course, there’s Cersei. . .

  4. I want to read this before the series starts coming out, so that I may turn up my nose at it if it doesn’t stay true to the books. :p (that’s not really why) I loooove Sean Bean and Peter Dinklage, not to mention Lena Headey ever since the live action Jungle Book, and I’m very excited for this series. Just have to read the books.

    (By the way, that Gaiman link appears to have a stray ” at the end of it that’s preventing it from working.)

    • I can’t wait to see Tyrion onscreen- it’s going to be wonderful. The first season will deal with the first book, according to Martin, so you don’t need to inhale the whole series for it to work for you.

      (And thank you! It’s been fixed.)

  5. This series does intimidate me a little bit, and like Eva I’m wary of the fact it hasn’t been finished. But on the other hand, you make it sound SO awesome. Want want want.

  6. A that I just did a reveiw of Feast For Crows, I’m curious how you feel about his ever growing delay between volumes?

    PS I agree with your favorite characters, particularly as they continue to grow through the different books.

    • That’s his business. I’d rather wait and get a solid book than have him rush and produce a poor one. He’s under no obligation to me to have the entire thing written out (which, in his case, would be nigh impossible) before publishing the first one. Essentially, I agree with Neil Gaiman on this issue.

  7. I haven’t read this series but I have definitely have heard of it. And I love that you are a fan of Nikolaj Coster-Waldau. Me too! Ever since that canceled show where he played an immortal detective in NYC.

  8. Great review. I agree with you, this book is a must!
    Especially now that the TV adaptation is in production!

    As for your intention to wait before you read the next instalment, let me just warn you that you might want to reconsider.

    First, the way GRRM tells the story, he manages to surprise everyone. Once big events happen, you will be dumbfounded as to how you didn’t see it coming and will fight an urge to go back and read it again to discover the clues you should have picked up but didn’t.
    Also, the huge epic scale of the story means a LOT of characters seemingly insignificant at first play a larger role later on, so you might be a little lost if you don’t remember who’s who, because GRRM loses no time on repeating introductions and orienting the reader. He leaves it to the reader to figure all of it out by themselves. He doesn’t take you by the hand. This is no children story. Don’t get me wrong, you’ll be able to enjoy the story even then. You’ll just miss out on a lot of great intricate stuff without noticing it.

    I read the first three novels about six years ago and wanted to reread them as soon as I’d finished. And I never reread a book in my entire life. I had the fourth instalment sitting on a shelf for five years, patiently waiting for the next book to come out so a reread from the start would be really worth it. With the TV adaptation now on its way and GRRM making good progress on finalising A Dance with Dragon, I figured now was an excellent time to start rereading. And I’m blown away by how many details escaped me the first time around and how cleverly interconnected every little pieces of the story are.

    In short, this is a book you will enjoy reading and rereading. Yes, you can read the second one next year and the third the next year. But you’ll soon find yourself wishing to reread the series from the start. Not because each book doesn’t stand on its own. They do. But because they’re so damn good.

    • I’m sure I will once I read the series, but since the first season focuses solely on A Game of Thrones, I’d like to read the next one after the season finale. Makes it last longer, although the rereads will definitely occur. 🙂

  9. Pingback: The Sunday Salon: 2010 in Review « The Literary Omnivore

  10. Pingback: Booking Through Thursday: Only Five « The Literary Omnivore

  11. Pingback: Page to Screen: Game of Thrones — Season One (2011) « The Literary Omnivore

Your Thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s