The Sunday Salon: Fantasy 101

As I tend to mention a great deal, I was reared on The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time and Peter Jackson’s The Lord of the Rings. If asked to choose one genre to read for the rest of my life, I’d happily answer fantasy. My reading resolutions were drawn up mostly to keep me from just gorging myself on fantasy and the occasional piece of science fiction and historical fiction. But I’m so happy swimming in the deep end that I rarely notice people at the edge tentatively dipping their toes in the pool. (It is, of course, a mana pool.) I know for people who haven’t read much fantasy that the genre can look intimidating, so today I’m going to recommend fantasy novels based on what other genres you enjoy. So take a deep breath and relax. This won’t hurt a bit.

For the Historical Fiction Fan

The Mists of Avalon by Marion Zimmer Bradley

The Mists of Avalon is a sweeping fantasy epic that looks at the Arthurian myths through the eyes of the women–Morgan le Fay, here known as Morgaine, especially. This is will be a very comforting read for historical fiction fans, I feel–obviously, it is historical fiction, and it deals with religious conflict, gender roles, and other themes historical fiction fans are probably comfortable with. It’s a fantasy because magic is quite real in this novel, but it’s treated as a matter of fact by the characters who have magical gifts. There’s nothing ridiculous or overblown about The Mists of Avalon, and it’s a literary classic in its own right–a perfect introduction to my beloved genre.

For Austenites

Tooth and Claw by Jo Walton

Yes, Austenites, there’s a fantasy novel for you! Tooth and Claw follows a family in something very like Victorian England as they are cheated out of their inheritance by a greedy and titled brother-in-law; as the men of the family seek rightful compensation, the women of the family look for husbands with less prospects than previously hoped. Oh, and they’re all dragons. While I’ll go more into it in my review on Wednesday, Walton pulls it off magnificently, translating class issues and gender issues into biology (oppressing the weak also involves devouring it, and female dragons truly can’t take care of themselves–they lack claws) in order to examine them. The novel is also compared to Trollope, but I feel anyone who enjoys Austen, especially her scathing views towards society, will enjoy Tooth and Claw.

For Young Adult Readers

Graceling by Kristin Cashore

Well, I think everyone should read Graceling, but for young adult readers and older readers who enjoy young adult fiction, Graceling is a great way to ease yourself into fantasy. Graceling follows Katsa, a young woman who works as her kingly uncle’s assassin since she is Graced with killing, sort of like a superpower–but secretly, Katsa is doing all she can to fight back against tyrants and evil-doers. Cashore’s world is very accessible, the internal logic makes sense (not always a guarantee in fantasy land), and Katsa is an interesting heroine that shows young women that you don’t have to compromise to have what you want and be who you want to be. On the off-chance that you don’t want to enter an entirely different world, then I suggest Rampant by Diana Peterfreund–it’s not as good as Graceling, but it’s still very good, and it’s set in our world with killer unicorns. Fun times for all!

For Mystery Fans

The Sword-Edged Blonde by Alex Bledsoe

The Sword-Edged Blonde‘s mystery heritage is more crime noir than cozy mystery, but I think it’ll appeal to readers of both because it doesn’t take the fantasy aspect of itself too seriously, but also creates a functioning world that’s easy to adapt to. The Sword-Edged Blonde follows Eddie La Crosse, a sword jockey for hire, as he is summoned by an old friend to look into a heinous murder case that requires him to look back into his checkered past. It’s fun, it’s readable, and it’s good–while it’s not perfect, it’s still a wonderful way to get into fantasy.

Of course, you can always just jump in the deep end by reading The Lord of the Rings (including The Hobbit as a prelude), which, since all modern fantasy is influenced by it, will give you all you need to start reading the genre, as well as being a classic of English literature. Then again, there’s nothing wrong with easing yourself in!

In other news, my reading has been going well–while I was disappointed in The Midnight Guardian, Racing the Dark is turning out to be very good. I also picked up Ivanhoe and The Gargoyle at the library on Friday after my volunteering shift, as well as Christian Siriano’s Fierce Style. (What? I can learn from the pocket-sized master of fierce.) Reviewing that last one ought to prove very interesting. My library is closed this weekend though, and won’t open until Tuesday, to my dismay, but between my rentals and books I actually own (including a thrift store copy of A Game of Thrones, to my utter delight), I ought to be more than prepared for a while.

Fantasy fans, help your fellow readers out–how should they approach the genre?

Oh, and happy Fourth of July from this American to all my American readers. 🙂

16 thoughts on “The Sunday Salon: Fantasy 101

  1. I don’t know. I started with children’s fantasy (when I was a child)–C.S. Lewis, E. Nesbit, Edward Eager, –and then I suppose I graduated to other, longer and more challenging books. I’ve still found nothing better than Tolkien, and I think some of the best fantasy being written nowadays is still classified young adult and children’s. Jessica Day George, Jane Yolen, Robin McKinley, Sarah Beth Durst, and Donna Jo Napoli come to mind.

  2. So I have never read any of these, which is a bit embarrassing. But I’m definitely going to read Tooth and Claw, at least, and maybe someday The Mists of Avalon, although I have always been slightly suspicious of Marion Zimmer Bradley. For some reason.

  3. I would add Guy Gavriel Kay to the “for Historical Fiction fans” list, since probably half of his books are listed as fantasy but have almost no traditional fantasy elements to them at all.

    I love Mists of Avalon, and I did in fact read it during the summer that I got back into fantasy as an adult. (I read fantasy all the time as a kid but sort of drifted away from it during my teens and early twenties.) I always have a problem with how to classify Arthuriana, though… it’s not proper historical fiction, but it’s at least vaguely historically based, so *not* calling it historical fiction feels wrong too.

    • I’ve actually learned of an interesting term for such fantasy novels- low fantasy, for fantasy novels without magic, mythical beasts, or other such traditional fantasy elements.

      Exactly! If it has fantasy elements, I think of an Arthur novel as a fantasy; if not, historical fiction. These lines can be so blurry!

      • I don’t think I like the term “low fantasy” – I can see how it’s contrasted to “high fantasy,” but it just sounds kind of demeaning and judgmental. I’ll stick with my slightly less-concise term “historical fantasy that’s not really fantasy but more historical fiction except it takes place in a country that didn’t actually exist, even though it’s heavily based on one that did.” 🙂

  4. Oh, Kristen Cashore is so brilliant. Her second book, “Fire,” is almost the equal of “Graceling,” although it takes longer to weave its web around you. I just finished a similar (incredibly gripping although not quite Cashore-level good) read: “Poison Study”. Have you read it?

    Other favorite fantasy as a way in? How about the incredibly literary Ursula K. Le Guin?

    • I haven’t, but I’ll add it to my list!

      I’ve only read Le Guin’s science fiction; A Wizard of Earthsea is in my bookshelf, calling to me, but I haven’t gotten around to it. I only wanted to recommend novels I’ve read and liked here, although I’m sure I’ll like A Wizard of Earthsea.

  5. Susan Cooper. Definitely. I would recommend her “Dark Is Rising Saga” for those who like Harry Potter (she published decades before, however). I would go into “The Dark Is Rising” first, because even though “Over Sea, Under Stone” is chronologically first, it’s very — British children’s book — and not everyone likes that.

    I also heart A Wizard of Earthsea and Robin McKinley muchly. I also like Jonathan Stroud’s Bartimaeus Trilogy, Neil Gaiman (but I definitely would start with Neverwhere or Anansi Boys or Good Omens), Terry Pratchett. . .

  6. A bunch of great reading there, by I’m a long-time fantasy reader. I can second (or is it third?) LeGuin for those just beginning to read fantasy or who are in search for young-adult fantasy.

    And as for fantasy being baaaaaad … yeah, I’d say it’s about the same percentage as most other genres. I mean, come one, there’s a ton of bad science fiction, romance, westerns, etc. out there on book shelves, but there’s also a fair amount of quality reading material, too. Fantasy unfortunately suffers from a few setbacks in the public’s eye, including covers that are often beyond geeky (though I feel this trend is changing), not that there’s anything wrong with being geeky. I’m a fantasy geek. But it’s not what the public usually buys into.

    For fantasy without magic, there’s the Gormenghast trilogy, but it’s a tough read for most and more literary than entertaining. Plus the third book suffers because it wasn’t finished before the author passed away.

Your Thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s